Feedback or validation?

Have you ever called a friend to ask for feedback on something and got so much negativity in return that left you angry?

‘Course you have! We all have experience of getting a major brain wave, urgently needing to run it by someone, but that someone tends to be a party pooper. If this happens to you often, your idea is NOT the problem.

Your expectation is.

When you seek ‘feedback’, you need to be absolutely sure that you are willing to be challenged. The purpose of feedback is to get an outsider’s perspective on your mental circus. And not everyone likes clowns.

But, if you don’t want to be challenged and want someone to say, “you go, girl!”, just ask for ‘validation’. A lot of us —  more so women from my study of an unrepresentative sample — seek external validation for the things we do. While we can all work on not needing that, there is no harm in asking for it in the meanwhile. 

Call the friend and say, “listen, I have an idea. I’m super excited. I need validation from you that I can make it happen”. Set the expectation straight. Don’t hope to receive validation and take it personally when you don’t get it. 

This is a double whammy. Because this way, when you ask for feedback, your friend will know you are willing to hear that your idea sucks. 🙂


Written by

Filed under

233 words
1–2 minutes

Some blog posts are several years old. While most concepts are still relevant, the practical applications might have changed for the AI era. Feel free to comment, if you’d like to discuss what I think of it now.

4 responses

  1. Nabha avatar
    Nabha

    Loved it. Looking forward to reading more.

    1. Ranjani avatar

      Thank you. <3

  2. SR avatar

    So, so true!But it’s something I’ve come to see as the “reviewer’s curse” – if you ask people for feedback, they feel they have failed in their duty if they can’t find at least 2-3 things to “improve.”Maybe setting the expectation from the get-go, like you said, might work. But (am I now being a party pooper here?) I suspect pessimism and negativity fit rather well under the cloak of “But I am simply protecting you from failure/disappointment down the line.”

    1. Ranjani avatar

      You know this is why I say just be honest and tell the truth. Too much mind-games isn’t good for anyone. I think the reviewer needs to give feedback within the context of the objectives and let it be. But if I call a friend and ask for validation, I expect to hear “you go, girl!” 😛

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *